Week 45 ·
Week 45: A Nordic Swan licence is not enough documentation
Three regulators rejected three different kinds of paperwork in nine days. Invita pointed at a Nordic Swan licence, Kärnfull pointed at the guarantees of origin it had bought, Apohem pointed at the product data its supplier had sent. All three lost. The common finding is that responsibility for a claim sits with whoever puts it in front of the consumer, and a certificate held by somebody else is not a defence. The Consumentenbond's PFAS work on Friday showed the other available response: of 34 companies asked, 30 did not give a full answer.
Regulation & policy
Denmark · Green claims · RetailDecision published 27 October 2026
A Nordic Swan licence is not documentation for the word "sustainable"
Denmark's Consumer Ombudsman found Nobia Denmark's marketing of the Invita "RE:New" kitchen renewal concept misleading. The claims at issue were "Et bæredygtigt valg" and "Med RE:New hjælper vi dig med at tage et bæredygtigt og mere klimasmart valg", running on invita.dk, in Meta ads and in an influencer post.
Invita's cabinet carcasses and some doors carry the Nordic Swan label. The Ombudsman held that this is not sufficient documentation for a general sustainability claim, because replacing doors and individual elements is a common alternative that many companies offer, so the concept carries no special climate or environmental benefit. Both the company and the influencer received a formal admonishment under markedsføringsloven §§ 5, 6, 8 and 13, with § 37(3) leaving fines available.
The influencer was separately admonished for hidden advertising: "#annonce" and "@invitadanmark" at the end of a post is not a clear enough disclosure, and two green sprout and two bee emojis were counted as part of the claim. Consumer Ombudsman Torben Jensen's advice is to use specific statements about actual environmental benefits rather than broad words like "bæredygtig".
The finding turns on documentation rather than intent. The label covered components; the claim covered the concept.
Sources: Forbrugerombudsmanden, press release, 27 October 2026 · In our data: Sustainability claims tracker
Netherlands · Durability · GuaranteesGuidance published 29 October 2026
ACM puts a minimum paper size on the EmpCo guarantee notice
The Dutch regulator ACM published guidance on the guarantee-information rules that have applied across the EU since 27 September 2026 under the EmpCo directive. There are two instruments. The statutory-guarantee notice is mandatory: in a physical shop it must be clearly visible and legible, for example on a poster of at least A4 at the till; online it must be available through a prominent link before the consumer buys, and mention in the terms and conditions is explicitly not sufficient. After purchase it must also be supplied on a durable medium, for example by email.
The second is the EU GARAN label. Producers are not obliged to offer a commercial durability guarantee, but where they do and it runs longer than two years, covers the whole product and is free, the label belongs with it. Where the producer makes that information available to the seller, the seller must inform consumers with the label; the seller is not required to go and ask the manufacturer. In a shop the label must sit visibly with the product, online it must appear just before purchase and again afterwards, and a reduced-size version is permitted online where space is limited.
Durability here is a disclosure obligation rather than a claim, which puts the information in front of shoppers who were not looking for it.
Sources: ACM, information page on the new European guarantee rules, 29 October 2026
Sweden · Reporting · OmnibusLagrådsremiss decided 27 October 2026
Sweden proposes to exempt small and mid-cap listed companies from sustainability reporting
The Swedish government decided a lagrådsremiss, "Lättnader i kraven på hållbarhetsrapportering", and sent it to the Council on Legislation. It raises the thresholds for which companies must produce a sustainability report, exempts some companies currently covered, and proposes that small and medium-sized listed companies be exempted from the obligation altogether.
Companies falling outside the scope could decline to supply more information up the value chain than the EU voluntary standard requires, sensitive information such as trade secrets could be withheld more broadly, and an auditor reviewing a sustainability report would need a specific authorisation for the assignment. The changes are proposed to enter into force on 19 March 2027, which is also the CSRD transposition deadline. It is a draft bill, not yet a proposition.
If it passes as drafted, a smaller share of Swedish listed companies will publish sustainability information at the point the reporting regime was originally meant to widen.
Consumer & brand
Netherlands · E-commerce · Say-do gapMonitor published 29 October 2026
52 per cent of Dutch online shoppers call sustainability important, and 13 per cent let it decide
Thuiswinkel.org's Duurzaamheid Monitor 2026 found 52 per cent of Dutch online shoppers call sustainability very or fairly important, up from 45 per cent in 2024. Then the numbers fall away: 17 per cent pay attention to sustainability aspects when choosing a product, and for 13 per cent it is decisive. 43 per cent never look for sustainability information at webshops at all, which the monitor itself describes as the main place such information sits.
Where consumers do want improvement, it is packaging. 47 per cent name more sustainable packaging as an important route, 40 per cent want less plastic, 16 per cent less overpackaging and 9 per cent less air, and well over three-quarters prefer cardboard to plastic on delivery. Director Marlene ten Ham's conclusion is that retailers can do a lot themselves, by making second-hand visible and defaulting to the lowest-CO2 delivery option. The monitor was made possible in part by DS Smith and Amazon.
The monitor reports the rise in stated importance and the low decisiveness figure side by side, which is the measurement problem in a single table.
Sources: Thuiswinkel.org, Duurzaamheid Monitor 2026, 29 October 2026 · In our data: What consumers want companies to focus on
Netherlands · Chemicals · TransparencyResearch published 30 October 2026
Asked about PFAS in their products, 30 of 34 companies did not give a full answer
The Dutch consumer organisation Consumentenbond put questions to 34 manufacturers and retailers about PFAS in their products and went through their websites. Four gave a full answer: Auping, Bosch-Siemens, LG and Sony. Eight did not respond at all, among them Philips, Samsung and Xiaomi. Albert Heijn, HEMA and Unilever sent short emails saying they do their best, with no concrete measures attached.
Only HEMA publishes an overview of PFAS-free products, covering pans and bakeware. No company publishes a list of products that do contain PFAS. Tefal's chatbot would not answer questions on the environmental damage caused by PTFE, and Etos's chatbot told shoppers to ask staff in store. Director Sandra Molenaar: "Consumenten kunnen hier helemaal niks mee", and "Soms sturen bedrijven consumenten zelfs willens en wetens het bos in".
One of the 34 publishes a positive list and none publishes a negative one, so a shopper trying to avoid PFAS has no product-level source to work from.
Sources: Consumentenbond, 30 October 2026 · Duurzaam Ondernemen, 30 October 2026
Sweden · Advertising · RetailRO decision dated 20 October 2026
A supplier's product feed wrote the claim, and the retailer was the one found at fault
Sweden's advertising ombudsman Reklamombudsmannen upheld a complaint against the pharmacy retailer Apohem over a product page selling "Kit & Kin Ekologiska Blöjor" at 184 kronor, described as "Ekologiska blöjor för nyfödda 2 till 5 kg". The diapers are not organic.
Apohem's defence was that its supplier had sent incorrect information, including the organic claims, and apologised once the error came to light. The products hold B Corp, Allergy Certified, Dermatest, FSC and Carbon Neutral Plant certifications, none of which is an organic certification. RO held that the average consumer in a broad target group would read "ekologiska" as meaning lower environmental impact or some other environmental advantage, found the claim misleading under ICC articles 5 and D2, and noted that correcting the page afterwards is desirable but does not make the breach acceptable.
The decision places responsibility with the party publishing the claim rather than the party that wrote it, which is a different kind of exposure for any retailer carrying third-party product data.
Sources: Reklamombudsmannen, case 2608-135, decided 20 October 2026
Client sectors
Denmark · Energy · Green claimsDecision published 28 October 2026
Buying the guarantee of origin is not the same as being allowed to say 100 per cent
Denmark's Consumer Ombudsman admonished the electricity retailer Kärnfull Energi over four claims: "En lysere fremtid med 100 % atomkraft", "100 % certificeret atomstrøm", "Skift til 100 % atomstrøm nu" and "Landets mest rationelle elaftale med 100 % atomkraft". Electricity from different sources mixes in the grid, so no supplier can promise single-source power at the socket; what it can buy is a guarantee of origin, meaning an amount matching the customer's consumption is fed in from that source.
Kärnfull's website did say the agreement rests on guarantees of origin and that customers would not receive 100 per cent nuclear power at the socket, but that sat separately from the claims, in an FAQ on an "about" page. The Ombudsman held that material information must be presented with the same visibility as the marketing itself. The case has a long run-up: Forbrugerrådet Tænk complained about the marketing of 16 electricity companies, the Ombudsman informed 13 of them of the rules in February 2026, and Kärnfull had already been guided in September 2025 with a deadline that passed unmet. The claims have since been removed or reworded. Provisions: markedsføringsloven §§ 5, 6 and 8, with § 37(3) allowing fines.
The decision is about placement as much as wording. The qualifying information existed, and the Ombudsman held that it was not where the claim was.
Sources: Forbrugerombudsmanden, press release, 28 October 2026
Sweden · Fuel · Target retreatStrategy presented 23 October 2026
Preem's new strategy has 2040 intensity targets and no 2035 climate-neutral date
VAROPreem, the company formed when Swiss VARO Energy acquired Preem in January 2026, presented its Value Growth Strategy to 2030 in Zug. The targets are financial and intensity-based: at least double EBITDA by 2030 against 2025, more than half of it from renewables and lower-carbon energy, market share in selected markets up from 10 to 15 per cent by 2030, close to USD 300 million of synergies through 2030, renewable fuel production capacity up 20 per cent by 2030, and cuts of 50 per cent in Scope 1 and 2 production intensity and 30 per cent in Scope 3 product intensity by 2040, both against 2018.
Preem had previously described becoming a climate-neutral company with a climate-neutral value chain by 2035 as necessary. That target does not appear in the new strategy, and Dagens Industri reported on the same day that it has been dropped. Petrol stations keep the Preem name. Chief executive Dev Sanyal's framing is that the company will keep supplying the fuels Europe needs while developing renewable alternatives.
Both of the new climate targets are intensity measures against a 2018 base, which is a different kind of promise from an absolute date.
Sources: VAROPreem, release via Cision, 23 October 2026 · Vi Bilägare, 23 October 2026 · In our data: Sustainable Brand Index rankings
